|B+ B+ B+|
|Review by Xibo||Date seen: May 4, 2005|
|Viewing Location: 42nd St. eWalk, NYC||Grade: B+|
|Summary: Funny and colorful, but a little off.|
|One of the problems with making this movie is that it has such a strong legacy to live up to. Both the book and radio show were excellent and groundbreaking, and the movie has to cram the story into two hours, which isn't quite enough time to tell it all, apparently. The movie was a lot of fun, and made me laugh in many places.
Many design choices were off, though. Marvin should have been more depressing-looking. They never went into Eddie's psyche. Choosing a black for Ford was interesting, but I would have preferred someone more cool and hip; Mos Def didn't quite do it for me. Trillian was very well done, and Arthur was okay. Zaphod seemed to be wrong, though. They played him more crazy than cocky, more stupid than bold. They did the whole two heads and third arm thing all wrong, too. I also didn't like the animation they used for the Guide. That could have been a lot better.
So. Funny movie, worth seeing, but falls short of excellence and doesn't live up to its legacy.
|A+ A+ A+|
|Review by Finrod||Date seen: April 29, 2005|
|Viewing Location: AMC Parkway Pointe 15, Cumberland||Grade: A+|
|Summary: Revised: a classic that grows on you if you let it|
Originally I said:
This movie may not have quite lived up to the reputation of the books et al, but I don't think there was any way it could have. A number of the jokes from the books were shortened or changed, and some things just plain done differently; but a good chunk of the stuff that was new in the movie was good and lived up to Douglas Adams's zany style, e.g. the 'point-of-view gun'. Alan Rickman as the voice of Marvin was the perfect casting role, and the other casting was generally good. Zaphod perhaps could have been a bit better, but like the first book, this movie wasn't centered on him.
I really hope it does well enough that we'll see The Restaurant at the End of the Universe in a couple years.
After seeing this movie again on dvd (late September), I've revised my grade from A- to A. Maybe I just picked up on the particular zen of it, but I really enjoyed it much more the second time around. I'm not even ruling out later raising my grade to A+.
After watching it a bunch of times, on dvd and on satellite movie channels, I've revised my grade to A+.
Now I really hope they make The Restaurant At The End Of The Universe soon.
|B- B- B-|
|Review by Jigen||Date seen: January 30, 2006|
|Viewing Location: DVD||Grade: B-|
|Summary: Not panicking.|
|It had to be very difficult to get this film made properly. Overall, the makers did a reasonably good job at balancing the fiction of the book with the necesseties of filmmaking. The humor is dry and hilarious. Characters silly and interactions light. I was never blown away though and people who haven't read the book might not always "get the joke". Even if the grade seems low, it doesn't measure how happy I was to see it made or how I really hope a sequel gets made as well.|
"I should put quotes here."